Ansel was famous for his manipulation, for those who have studied him. That "W" he removed from the mountainside was more difficult back then, when dodging/burning were the tools. It's a lot easier with Photoshop, using "Clone Stamp" or "Healing Brush" or whatever tool you prefer. But the effect is pretty much identical.
I personally think it's this: Many people, once they learned to do something that they feel is difficult, don't want others to be able to match their accomplishments. So they make up rules like "no manipulation" to separate themselves, to feel important. It's a common trait of people in just about every field, to erect artificial barriers in an effort to seem elite. That's sad, but I think that's the biggest reason this is a "thing".
Thoughtful observations and perspective. I agree and I think there is another class of critic, like my friend. I think they don’t truly view photography as art and therefore imply it’s not subject to interpretation/modification by the artist/photographer. Those types are the hardest to convince of the artistic value to photography in the way you and I might.
Great article to republish, Ward!
Ansel was famous for his manipulation, for those who have studied him. That "W" he removed from the mountainside was more difficult back then, when dodging/burning were the tools. It's a lot easier with Photoshop, using "Clone Stamp" or "Healing Brush" or whatever tool you prefer. But the effect is pretty much identical.
I personally think it's this: Many people, once they learned to do something that they feel is difficult, don't want others to be able to match their accomplishments. So they make up rules like "no manipulation" to separate themselves, to feel important. It's a common trait of people in just about every field, to erect artificial barriers in an effort to seem elite. That's sad, but I think that's the biggest reason this is a "thing".
Hello, Donn!
Thoughtful observations and perspective. I agree and I think there is another class of critic, like my friend. I think they don’t truly view photography as art and therefore imply it’s not subject to interpretation/modification by the artist/photographer. Those types are the hardest to convince of the artistic value to photography in the way you and I might.
Regards!